The Hidden Cost of Persuasion
When clarity quietly turns into control
I’ll start with a confession.
After years in copywriting, resisting the urge to persuade feels like unlearning a reflex.
I’ve written it all: sales pages, ad campaigns, launch sequences, webinar scripts. The mechanics of influence became second nature. Identify a shared problem. Stir the emotion it triggers. Then link that emotion to the solution you’re offering.
And it works.
The reader feels seen. They follow the rhythm of your logic. Before they’ve had a chance to step back, they’re nodding along, absorbing your perspective as if it were their own.
That’s the power of persuasion. When done well, it’s smooth, seamless, and nearly invisible.
But that’s also what makes it tricky.
At some point, I realized I wasn’t just presenting ideas. I was scripting responses. The reader wasn’t discovering insight for themselves. They were being guided there, one emotional cue at a time.
What I had mistaken for clarity was often control in disguise. And what I thought was resonance was, at times, just a well-engineered agreement.
Some would argue this is exactly what people want. Certainty in a chaotic world. Clean answers. A steady voice telling them what matters and what to do next.
Maybe that’s true.
But at what cost?
What happens when people grow used to outsourcing their thinking? When they come to rely on someone else to name the problem, trigger the feeling, and provide the solution? When clarity is no longer something they arrive at themselves, but something handed to them fully formed?
Persuasion shortens the path to agreement. Reflection slows it down.
And in a culture obsessed with speed, that difference matters.
I don’t think persuasion is inherently wrong. But I do think it’s worth noticing how easily it becomes the default mode of communication—especially online, where attention is scarce and competition is relentless.
The emotional hooks. The manufactured urgency. The feeling of “this makes sense” arriving just a bit too quickly.
Sometimes that feeling isn’t understanding. It’s compliance.
That realization forced me to question not just how I write, but why. Whether my work was helping people think more clearly—or simply making it easier for them to agree with me.
And once that question enters the room, it doesn’t leave quietly.
What you just read is a short public passage. The full, long-form essays are shared every Tuesday through my private email list, not on Substack. If you’d like to receive them, subscribe: