Why Reflection Feels So Uncomfortable Online
And why that discomfort matters
When writing invites reflection instead of agreement, discomfort is inevitable.
Not metaphorical discomfort. Real, bodily discomfort.
Cognitively, emotionally, even viscerally, something shifts. The reader is no longer consuming ideas that confirm what they already believe. They’re being asked to hold tension—between what feels familiar and what’s being gently questioned.
And that’s when something primal kicks in.
The nervous system doesn’t care whether an idea is thoughtful or nuanced. It cares about safety. So it reacts: fight, flight, scroll.
Close the tab. Move on. Find something smoother. Something clearer. Something that reassures instead of challenges.
In a culture saturated with speed and certainty, discomfort isn’t something we’re taught to stay with. It’s something we’re trained to escape.
That’s not a moral failing. It’s conditioning.
We know what performs online. Urgency. Certainty. Emotional charge. Writing that makes people feel something quickly, without friction.
Reflection does the opposite. It slows things down. It creates pauses. It asks the reader to participate rather than consume.
And that’s terrible for metrics.
Thoughtful writing doesn’t always get shared. It doesn’t always get liked. It rarely converts cleanly. It introduces hesitation where platforms reward immediacy.
So the temptation is always there: smooth the edges. Add urgency. Package complexity into something easier to digest.
Meet people exactly where they are—and never ask them to stretch.
But if we claim to write for impact, not just performance, that’s the tension we have to hold.
To resist the shortcut of telling people what to think. To sit with complexity long enough for something honest to emerge. To trust that discomfort isn’t a failure of communication—but often a sign that real thinking has begun.
Reflection creates dissonance before it creates insight.
And dissonance, by its nature, feels unsafe at first.
The problem isn’t that people can’t think deeply. It’s that the environments we inhabit don’t reward it. They reward certainty, repetition, and emotional resolution.
So when reflective writing struggles online, it’s not because it lacks value. It’s because it asks something the system isn’t built to support.
That doesn’t mean it’s pointless.
It just means it’s playing a different game.
What you just read is a short public passage. The full, long-form essays are shared every Tuesday through my private email list, not on Substack. If you’d like to receive them, subscribe: